- Works well as both a tablet and a laptop
- New Type Cover and Surface Pen are massive improvements
- Still pretty thin and light for the equivalent of an ultraportable
- Mediocre battery life
- Type Cover is an additional $130
The Surface Pro 4 builds on the best parts of the Surface Pro 3, and it finally delivers a solid typing experience with the revamped Type Cover (which is unfortunately sold separately). It’s the ideal hybrid tablet in practically every way — it’s as light as a tablet, but as productive as any laptop. The only problem is you’re stuck with so-so battery life.
It’s probably fair to describe the Surface Pro 4 as an evolutionary update over its predecessor. That’s not to say the improvements, collectively, aren’t impressive: more of the same, or similar, is no bad thing when you’re talking about a tablet that in its several generations has built a loyal following.
This time around, Microsoft delivers the always-pleasing combination of more functionality with less space. The screen is slightly larger, at 12.3-inches versus the 12-inches of the Surface Pro 3, but more noticeable is the reduction in weight and thickness.
More than half a centimeter has been pared off, cutting the Surface Pro 4 to 8.4mm thick rather than the 9.1mm of before, and it’s lighter too. The Core m3 model is the most waif-like of the new line-up, at a mere 1.69 pounds, while the Core i5 and i7 versions tip the scales at 1.73 pounds apiece, still less than the 1.76 pounds of the old tablet.
You notice that trimming in just how easily you can hold the Pro 4 for extended periods, though of course there’s Microsoft’s well-esteemed multi angle kickstand to prop it up on a table-top or lap.
The Surface Type Keyboard has been redesigned, too. It still relies on the dog-leg double hinge with two sets of magnets to reduce potential twisting when you’ve got it on your lap, but now the keys themselves are better spaced and they have more travel.
The trackpad is glass, and 40-percent larger than on the old Type Cover. It supports five-finger multitouch too. In a minor annoyance it has a fairly loud click, but generally I’m a big fan of how smooth and responsive it is.
No, you’re not going to mistake the Type Cover for a true laptop keyboard – if that’s what you’re looking for then please, step this way, because Microsoft would love to introduce you to the Surface Book – but I’ve been surprised at just how good it is to type on now. There’s still some bounce under your fingertips, but I’d be less frustrated at coughing up the $130 Microsoft still asks for it as an accessory.
Later on, you’ll be able to pay even more – $150, in fact – for a version with a fingerprint scanner. Unfortunately that wasn’t available for me to review, and it’s worth noting that only those in the US will get it.
What everyone gets is the redesigned Surface Pen. That clings magnetically to the side of the tablet rather than slotting into the fabric loop of the Pro 3, which initially I was pleased to see as it seems a lot more elegant a solution.
In practice, though, I’ve had a few occasions where the pen ha been knocked off its perch in my bag, and I’ve had to go hunting for it amid the receipts and loose thumbdrives lurking at the bottom.
It’s worth chasing down, because it’s been improved in a number of ways over the old pen. For a start it’ll recognize more levels of pressure – now 1,024 – for more lifelike digital inking, and you can now switch out the tips to give the feel of different real-world styluses.
How often people will actually do that is questionable, but I found the default tip provided a good balance of friction and slickness for handwriting and my awful excuses at sketching.
On the top, the button is now also an eraser – flip the stylus over and rub out your mistakes – while also acting as a shortcut trigger. Click it once and OneNote opens up with a blank note ready; double-click it, and you get a screenshot first that’s pasted into OneNote for annotation.
Clicking and holding the button summons Cortana, the virtual assistant first offered on Windows Phone and now part of Windows 10. Clever stuff, but I do wish you could remap the clicks to other apps if you’re not a devotee of OneNote.
The pen connects via Bluetooth 4.0LE, suitably power-sipping so that a single AAAA battery should last for a year of use according to Microsoft. Unfortunately there’s no microphone built in, so even though the range is enough to rouse Cortana from across a wide room, you’ll have to shout if you want her to hear you.
Microsoft has three tiers of Surface Pro 4, with the most affordable being the Core m3 starting at $899, a Core i5 from $1,299, and finally a Core i7 from $1,599. All use SSDs, ranging from 128GB to 1TB, and offer a choice of 4GB to 16GB of memory.
Intel’s Core m3 – even in latest Skylake form – might be lacking in power for more than the usual bevy of desktop apps along with media consumption; you get Intel HD graphics 515, too. Step up to the Core i5, like the review unit Microsoft provided me with, and the GPU improve to Intel HD 520. Only the Core i7 version gets Intel Iris graphics.
I ran Geekbench, a test of processor and memory performance, and the Surface Pro 4 scored 3,176 in the single-core benchmark and 6,749 in the multi-core. In contrast, last year’s Core i5 Surface Pro 3 scored 2,900 and 5,608 in the same tests, respectively.
After that, I turned to 3DMark Pro, a graphics test. Without a discrete GPU like the NVIDIA chip in the Surface Book, my expectations weren’t dramatic; in fact, the Surface Pro 4 scored 851 in the toughest Fire Strike benchmark, and 3,582 in the more mainstream Sky Diver test. It’s worth noting that those figures outperform the Core i5 Surface Book, albeit the model with onboard Intel graphics alone.
In practice, I had no issues with apps loading swiftly, the tablet resuming from standby in split-seconds, and multitasking between apps.
WiFi a/b/g/n/ac is standard across the board, along with Bluetooth 4.0. Ports include a full-sized USB 3.0, Mini DisplayPort – I’d have preferred HDMI, but that’s just me – a headset jack, and microSD reader. I’ll have to agree to disagree with Microsoft’s decision that the market isn’t quite ready for USB-C (someone clearly needs to tell the Lumia team that, as the 950 has it)
The front camera is 5-megapixels now, while the rear gets 8-megapixels and autofocus; I’d rather you weren’t a tablet photographer, but it’s handy for snapping legible images of documents and business cards as an impromptu scanner.
Disappointingly, Microsoft still refuses to bake in LTE or GPS. I’ll drown my sadness in the excellent PixelSense display. Its 2736 x 1824 resolution – for 267 ppi pixel density – is only part of the Surface Pro 4’s story: what makes a difference is also how close that LCD panel is to your fingertips, thanks to a ridiculously thin optical stack topped with a protective sheet of Gorilla Glass 4.
It’s a stunning panel. Text is crisp and colors vivid, and I’m a fan of the 3:2 aspect ratio that doesn’t look ridiculous in either portrait or landscape orientation.
Then there’s battery life. Microsoft is promising up to nine hours of use, though that’s based on video playback. Taking advantage of the more potent graphics chips or doing anything more CPU intensive is obviously going to reduce that further.
With mixed use of browsing, emailing, some YouTube videos, and some handwritten notes and sketching, I saw around seven hours before I needed to reach for the magnetic charger.
Performance and battery life
|PCMARK7||PCMARK8 (CREATIVE ACCELERATED)||3DMARK11||3DMARK (SKY DIVER)||ATTO (TOP READS/WRITES)|
|Surface Pro 4 (2.4GHz Core i5-6300U, Intel HD 520)||5,403||3,602||E2,697/ P1,556/ X422||3,614||1.6 GB/s / 529 MB/s|
|Surface Pro 3 (1.9GHz Core i5-4300U, Intel HD 4400)||5,024||N/A||E1,313 / P984||N/A||555 MB/s / 252 MB/s|
|Surface Book (2.4GHz Core i5-6300U, Intel HD 520)||5,412||3,610||E2758 / P1578 / X429||3,623||1.6 GB/s / 571 MB/s|
|Surface Book (2.6GHz Core i7-6600U, 1GB NVIDIA GeForce graphics)||5,740||3,850||E4122 / P2696||6,191||1.55 GB/s / 608 MB/s|
|Lenovo LaVie Z(2.4GHz Intel Core i7-5500U, Intel HD 5500)||5,232||N/A||E2001/ P1122 / X310||N/A||555 MB/s / 245 MB/s|
|HP Spectre x360(2015, 2.2GHz Intel Core i5-5200U, Intel HD 5500)||4,965||N/A||E1667 / P932 / X265||N/A||555 MB/s / 270 MB/s|
|Dell XPS 13 (2015, 2.2GHz Intel Core i5-5200U, Intel HD 5500)||4,900||N/A||E2114 / P1199 / X330||N/A||515 MB/s / 455 MB/s|
When it comes down to pure computational performance, I didn’t feel a huge difference between the Surface Pro 4 and the Pro 3. I’m testing a Core i5 model running at 2.4GHz with 8GB of RAM, so sure, it’s technically zippier than the Core i5 I tested last year. It’s a particularly big jump if you’re dealing with media editing, where the significantly faster disk speeds will be very noticeable. Really, though, it’s more useful to look at the productivity benefits the Surface Pro 4 delivers with the new Surface Pen and Type Cover. And in that respect, it’s a night-and-day difference from its predecessor.
Transcribing isn’t fun, folks — the fact that I was able to jot down a lengthy and dense interview with the new Type Cover in a less-than-ideal seating situation, with the Surface balanced on my lap, is worth praising. I also didn’t have any trouble fitting the Surface Pro 4 into my daily workflow, which is something the Pro 3 never quite achieved. Microsoft has finally managed to build a Surface that can keep up with me productivity-wise. That’s a huge win.
|Surface Pro 4||7:15|
|Surface Book (Core i5, integrated graphics)||13:54 / 3:20 (tablet only)|
|Surface Book (Core i7, discrete graphics)||11:31 / 3:02 (tablet only)|
|MacBook Air (13-inch, 2013)||12:51|
|HP Spectre x360||11:34|
|Apple MacBook Pro with Retina display (13-inch, 2015)||11:23|
|Chromebook Pixel (2015)||10:01|
|Microsoft Surface 3||9:11|
|Apple MacBook (2015)||7:47|
|Dell XPS 13 (2015)||7:36|
|Lenovo Yoga 3 Pro||7:36|
|Lenovo LaVie Z||7:32|
|Microsoft Surface Pro 3||7:08|
|Lenovo LaVie Z 360||6:54|
Despite being a huge leap forward in many ways, the Surface Pro 4 still falters in one critical area: battery life. In typical daily usage, which mostly consists of lots of web browsing, some image editing, constant Spotify streaming and a bunch of Slack messaging, it usually lasted me between five and seven hours. In our standard rundown test (looping a video until the battery dies), it lasted around seven hours and 15 minutes. That’s pretty disappointing for a flagship device in 2015 — especially when the MacBook Air has been getting almost double that amount for a few years now (it’s worth noting that the super-thin MacBook clocks only 7:47 in our test). Of course, the Surface Pro 4’s svelte design limits the size of the battery Microsoft can actually fit in, but it’s still a shame that it won’t last a full workday.
The OEMs might not like it, but Microsoft is probably responsible for the best Windows hardware out there today. Considered design, attention to detail, and an eagerness to look beyond off-the-shelf components add up to a tablet with charm as well as substance.
Should existing Surface Pro 3 owners upgrade? My gut feeling is no, with the exception of the new Type Cover. That, usefully, is backward compatible with the older tablet.
If you’re looking for a tablet that’s also a PC, something that’s portable and yet runs all the full Windows apps you might demand, then the Surface Pro 4 refiners what made its predecessors so impressive. As well as ticking the core boxes of display, portability, and functionality, it does so with style.
(slashgear.com & engadget.com)