New Renault Megane RS vs Honda Civic Type R vs Volkswagen Golf R Comparison

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

What’s the best hot hatch on sale today? To find out we’re pitting the new Renault Megane RS against our reigning champion, the Honda Civic Type R, and Volkswagen’s freshly tweaked Golf R

The contenders

*** NOTE : £1 = $1.32 (correct at time of post)

Honda Civic Type R 2.0 VTEC Turbo

  • List price £31,525
  • Target Price £31,300

Our 2018 Hot Hatch of the Year is a truly extraordinary driver’s car. It’ll be very tough to beat.

New Renault Megane RS 1.8 280 Cup

  • List price £28,995
  • Target Price £28,995

The previous Megane RS was one of the greatest hot hatches ever, so hopes are Eiffell Tower high.

Volkswagen Golf R 2.0 TSI 300 DSG

  • List price £34,910
  • Target Price £31,873

Range-topping Golf now comes excusively with five doors and a DSG automatic gearbox.

Renault Megane RS, Honda Civic Type R and Volkswagen Golf R

What do shoulder pads, denim jackets and hot hatchbacks have in common? They’re all 1980s fashion trends that are enjoying something of a renaissance this summer.

That’s pretty much where our knowledge of the latest clothing fads begins and ends, but we do know a thing or two about hot hatches – and already this year we’ve seen some corkers, including a new Ford Fiesta ST, GTI versions of the Volkswagen Up and Polo and a new Suzuki Swift Sport.

And for those with bigger budgets, there’s now a new Renault Mégane RS, making its debut here in hardcore Cup form. It’s the car that hot hatch fans have been salivating at the prospect of ever since its predecessor – a multi-time What Car? award winner and one of the most fun-to-drive cars ever made – was axed last year.

To even get close to the success of its predecessor, the new Mégane RS will have to see off some seriously tough competition, though. First in line is our 2018 Hot Hatch of the Year, the mighty Honda Civic Type R, but there’s also the Volkswagen Golf R – a four-wheel-drive brute that has recently been tweaked to make it less powerful (yes, you read that correctly) than before. Read on and we’ll explain all.

Driving – Performance, ride, handling, refinement

You could argue that 0-60mph times aren’t particularly relevant as a performance benchmark. After all, how often do you find yourself at the front of a queue at traffic lights with a derestricted stretch of the grey stuff ahead? Still, it’s nice to know you could embarrass your mates if you wanted to, and the four-wheel-drive Golf will do that with ease.

Its standard DSG automatic gearbox has a clever launch control system that allows even the most ham-fisted driver to make the perfect getaway, catapulting you to 60mph in well under five seconds. Our test car managed 4.5sec, but its 2.0-litre turbocharged engine was producing 306bhp; you’ll get 296bhp if you order one now. The small power drop is down to new fuel economy regulations that come into force in September.

The Civic’s engine – also a 2.0-litre turbo – packs even more punch than the Golf’s, producing 316bhp. However, because the Civic is front-wheel drive, there’s a limit to how much of that power you can actually transfer to the road off the line. We managed 0-60mph in 5.4sec, although that requires delicate use of the accelerator and clutch pedals. Adopt an aggressive approach and you’ll just sit there in a cloud of tyre smoke. The Golf and Civic are more closely matched when it comes to rolling acceleration – between, say, 30 and 70mph – although the former still edges it.

The Mégane is left trailing well behind. Its 276bhp 1.8-litre engine is massively outgunned not only for power but also torque – the sort of low-rev muscle that allows you to build speed when you don’t want to thrash the engine to its redline. It still managed a credible 0-60mph time of 5.9sec, though.

The Mégane sounds suitably special, too – especially in Race mode, when it growls with real purpose when you floor the accelerator. The Golf is even louder when specified with the optional Akrapovic exhaust, although the bassy drone isn’t especially tuneful. We can think of far better ways to spend £2975.

Despite its suggestive triple-exit exhaust, the Civic sounds a wee bit clinical next to its rivals. The whooshing sound it makes when you accelerate hard is reminiscent of a jumbo jet during take-off; it leaves you in no doubt that lots of power is being produced but doesn’t really tickle the soul.

That said, there’s real pleasure to be had from using the Civic’s ideally positioned gear lever; swapping cogs requires the merest flick of your wrist. The Mégane’s gearbox is a bit stiff by comparison, although it’s precise enough once you’ve made the extra effort. A dual-clutch automatic is available for £1700, but we’d stick with the manual.

The Golf’s standard auto ’box is also the dual-clutch variety, so shifts are blink-of-an-eye quick, although they don’t always happen quite when you want them to during hard driving.

Our 0.9-mile test track is designed to simulate a meandering B-road, giving an objective benchmark to find out which of our contenders has the highest handling limits. The Civic lapped quickest, crossing the line 0.3sec ahead of the Mégane; its secret is staying incredibly composed and balanced through high-speed corners and stable under hard braking. With a clever limited-slip differential (LSD) distributing power to whichever front wheel can cope with it best, it can claw its way out of slow corners far more effectively than most front-wheel-drive cars, too.

But not quite as effectively as the Mégane, which has a more aggressive LSD to drag you around corners with even more verve. The Mégane also has standard four-wheel steering, allowing the car to pivot itself around slower corners to further improve agility. At really low speeds, it can feel a bit like you’re piloting a shopping trolley, but it’s remarkably effective between 30mph and 60mph.

The drawback of the Mégane’s super-aggressive attitude is that it wants to follow cambers in the road as if there’s a poltergeist trapped in the steering rack; the wheel tugs left and right in your hands, especially when accelerating hard. You do at least get a good sensation of what the front wheels are doing, though, and on smooth roads it’s easy to place the car where you want it. Not quite with the same accuracy as you can in the Civic, though; its steering is more precise and less prone to corruption from road surfaces and hard acceleration.

The Golf, drag race champion though it may be, simply couldn’t keep up with its stiffer, more focused rivals through the twisty bits of our test track. It consistently lapped nearly a second slower than the Mégane and 1.2sec slower than the Civic, swaying about the most and feeling the least stable under hard braking. Its steering is pleasingly natural in weight but a bit vague compared with its rivals’ when you’re pushing hard.

And what about when you’re not in the mood for all that lark and just want to get to where you’re going in comfort? Well, despite having the biggest wheels (20in), the Civic is easily the most forgiving of the three, smoothing over lumps and ridges better than many regular family hatchbacks. Its standard adaptive dampers deserve much of the credit here; they allow you to stiffen or soften the suspension at your whim.

Our test Golf also had adaptive dampers fitted (at a cost of £850), along with 19in wheels – an inch larger than standard. In this form, it isn’t far behind the Civic for comfort. Meanwhile, the Mégane is by far the firmest and isn’t available with adaptive dampers at all, although it’s still (just) on the right side of acceptable – even if you opt for 19in wheels (£950) over the 18s you get as standard.

Mind you, the Civic is the noisiest motorway cruiser; its engine never really shuts up and there’s lots of tyre roar. The Megane is, perhaps surprisingly, the most peaceful at a steady 70mph. It’s still far from a luxury limo, though, because you’re acutely aware of the tyres slapping against the surface of the road and the wind whistling around the windscreen pillars.

Honda Civic Type R dashboard

Behind the wheel – Driving position, visibility, build quality

A good driving position is important in any car, but it’s even more crucial in anything likely to be tearing around corners. The Civic’s is tough to fault; you sit suitably low in the car, the seat supports you in all the right places and the pedals line up neatly with the steering wheel. We only wish the brake and accelerator pedals were slightly closer together.

The spacing of the Mégane’s pedals is better suited to fast driving, and its seat holds you in place just as well as the Civic’s through corners. However, the driving position won’t appeal to everyone, because the seat base is angled up towards the front of the car, so it can feel like you’re sitting in a really supportive deck chair.

The Golf’s driving position is, well, just like any other Golf’s. That’s mostly a good thing, although the seats are more like the pews you’d find in a regular hatch, so they aren’t ideal for hard driving. They’re comfortable the rest of the time, though.

Infotainment systems

Honda Civic Type R

This is the Civic’s biggest shortcoming – and it’s all the more frustrating when you consider how great the rest of the car is. The screen is low in resolution and the fact it’s angled upwards means it reflects sunlight badly. The menus are hopelessly complicated, the screen is often slow to respond to presses and even tweaking the volume is immensely frustrating. At least smartphone mirroring is standard.

Renault Megane RS

Better than the Civic’s system – but not by a lot. As standard, you get a 7.0in touchscreen with sat-nav, a DAB radio and Apple and Android smartphone mirroring. An extra £300 gets you a larger 8.7in screen (pictured). Either way, though, the menus aren’t very user-friendly and the screen is rather dull compared with the Golf’s. A powerful seven-speaker Bose sound system is available but adds £800 to the bill.

Volkswagen Golf R

Easily the best system here. The 8.0in touchscreen is super bright and responds almost instantaneously when you prod it. The fact the menus are logically arranged also aids usability. You can upgrade to a 9.2in screen (for £1325) but, frankly, we wouldn’t bother. We’d also steer clear of the clunky voice control (£200), although the Dynaudio Excite sound system (£550) is worth a look if you really love your music.

Honda Civic Type R rear seats

Space and practicality – Front space, rear space, seating flexibility, boot

This area is unlikely to be your top priority, but one of the advantages of hot hatches over proper sports cars such as the Mazda MX-5 is that you don’t have to leave your kids at home – unless you want to, of course.

The Civic is the roomiest in the back; it doesn’t have quite as much head room as its rivals, but there’s loads more leg room. The Mégane would be your last choice if you had to sit in the back.

It’s an easy win for the Civic when it comes to boot space, too. It has the longest and tallest load bay and swallowed the most carry-on suitcases (seven). The Mégane accepted five and the Golf four, although the former has the narrowest boot opening and the biggest lip to negotiate when you’re lifting stuff in and out.

Honda Civic Type R

  • Boot 420-1209 litres
  • Suitcases 7

Renault Megane RS

  • Boot tbc
  • Suitcases 5

Volkswagen Golf R

  • Boot 343-1233 litres
  • Suitcases 4

Buying and owning – Costs, equipment, reliability, safety and security

Honda Civic Type R side

We’ll keep this bit short, because it isn’t that complicated: the Mégane is the cheapest option and the Golf, by some margin, the most expensive. That’s true no matter whether you’re paying cash, signing up to a PCP finance deal or a company car driver – and it remains the case after you’ve factored in all the bills you’re likely to face over three years.

There isn’t much in it for luxuries, although the Mégane is the only one of our trio without standard adaptive cruise control to automatically maintain a set distance from the car in front. Meanwhile, the Golf is the only one with heated front seats but also the only one without standard keyless entry.

It’s very disappointing that Renault doesn’t fit any modern safety kit as standard, though. The Civic and Golf both come with automatic emergency braking as standard, while the latter also has lane-keeping assistance and traffic sign recognition.

verdict

The Golf R has many strengths, but the majority them aren’t the sort that make a great hot hatch. Yes, it’s devastatingly fast in a straight line, but it’s outclassed through the corners and is very expensive – particularly if you’re buying on PCP finance. If it’s the classy interior, decent practicality and VW badge that appeal, the Golf GTI offers those things for a lot less cash.

Renault Megane RS, Honda Civic Type R and Volkswagen Golf R

The fight for the win is tighter affair and the Civic and Megane are undoubtedly two of the finest hot hatches you can buy. The Civic will cost you more to buy and own, but we reckon it’s worth the premium. It’s a wonderfully well-engineered machine that’s both astonishing capable and great fun. The fact it’s so easy to live with only adds to its appeal.

The Megane isn’t the best all-rounder, but the way it changes direction embarrasses even the Civic, and the fact it’s so much cheaper than its rivals means it still deserves a five-star rating.

1st – Honda Civic Type R

  • For Staggering high-speed cornering ability; brilliant gearshift; driving position; easily the most practical
  • Against Terrible infotainment system; road noise
  • Recommended options None
Specifications: Honda Civic Type R 2.0 VTEC Turbo
  • Engine size 4cyl, 1996cc, turbo petrol
  • List price £31,525
  • Target Price £31,300
  • Power 316bhp @ 6500rpm
  • Torque 295Ib ft @ 2500-4500rpm
  • Gearbox 6-spd manual
  • 0-60mph 5.4sec
  • Top speed 169mph
  • Gov’t fuel economy 35.1mpg
  • CO2 emissions 176g/km
2nd – Renault Megane RS

  • For Incredible agility; sweet-sounding engine; cheap in this company
  • Against So-so performance; firm ride; you’ll want to add a few options
  • Recommended options 19in alloys (£950); metallic paint (from £550); Safety Pack Premium £400)
Specifications: Renault Megane RS 1.8 280 Cup
  • Engine size 4cyl, 1798cc, turbo petrol
  • List price £28,995
  • Target Price £28,995
  • Power 276bhp @ 6000rpm
  • Torque 287Ib ft @ 2400rpm
  • Gearbox 6-spd manual
  • 0-60mph 5.9sec
  • Top speed 158mph
  • Gov’t fuel economy 39.8mpg
  • CO2 emissions 161g/km
3rd – Volkswagen Golf R

  • For Devastatingly fast; reasonably quiet and comfy by hot hatch standards; classiest interior
  • Against Shown up through the bends; most expensive to buy and own; smallest boot
  • Recommended options Metallic paint (£575)
Specifications: Volkswagen Golf R 2.0 TSI 300 DSG
  • Engine size 4cyl, 1984cc, turbo petrol
  • List price £34,910
  • Target Price £31,873
  • Power 296bhp @ tbc
  • Torque tbc
  • Gearbox 6-spd manual
  • 0-60mph 4.5sec
  • Top speed 155mph
  • Gov’t fuel economy tbc
  • CO2 emissions tbc

(whatcar.com, http://bit.ly/2KJsXAv)

Comments

comments

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn