2017 Jaguar F-Pace S vs. 2017 Porsche Macan GTS – Comparison Tests

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Jaguar and Porsche prove that an elevated center of gravity and a mainstream mission need not preclude a serious sense of fun.

In an industry that lives and dies by the sales of Camrys and pickup trucks, advocating for enthusiasts sometimes feels like standing in a raging river and shouting at it to reverse course. Manu­al transmissions are slipping toward oblivion. Fuel-economy regulations are driving diversity from manufacturers’ engine port­folios, replacing it with efficient homogeneity. And perhaps most worrying is the proliferation of crossovers. They’re like an algal bloom threatening to choke out all other life-forms in the interest of easy ingress and a commanding driver’s position.

But a few shafts of light have started to pierce the heavy blanket of crossover conformity. Porsche’s first glimmer of hope, the Cayenne, dates to before most people realized the market potential of a high-performance crossover. In its first year on the market, the Cayenne became Porsche’s best-selling model. The creators of the Pink Pig learned lessons from their new 5000-pound supersow, and the smaller, Audi Q5–based Macan has already dethroned the Cayenne as the brand’s sales leader. The example tested here is the new-for-2017 GTS, which splits the difference between the $55,450, 340-hp S model and the $77,050, 400-horse Turbo.

Revised ECU tuning boosts the Macan GTS’s output over the S’s to 360 horsepower and 369 pound-feet, while standard adjustable air springs lower ride height by 0.4 inch. Like other Macans, the GTS is only available as an all-wheel-driver with a seven-speed PDK dual-clutch transmission. This example’s $68,250 base price swelled to an as-tested sticker of $77,255. Notable extras include the Premium ­Package Plus ($3390; panoramic sunroof, heated seats front and rear, keyless entry and starting, and auto-dimming mirrors), brake-based torque vectoring ($1490), the Sport Chrono package ($1290; dash-mounted stopwatch, launch control, and sport-plus mode for harder-edged suspension and drivetrain responses), and a key painted to match the car (cost to you: $525; cost to Porsche: maybe a buck). Any color other than simple black or white also costs extra, and our Volcano Grey Metallic lists for $690. The Carmine Red on our cover Macan? $3120.

Jaguar’s beacon of hope is new for 2017. Never mind that Land Rover functions as the SUV arm of jointly owned Jaguar Land Rover; to get Americans to pay attention, every brand needs its own crossover. Jaguar plows a lot of aluminum into the F-Pace, using the lightweight stuff for most of the body structure and suspension components. A diesel four-cylinder is the base engine, but the likely volume engines are a pair of aluminum V-6s shared with the F-type.

Displacing 3.0 liters and pumped full of 13.8 pounds of boost by an honest-to-John-Force Roots-type supercharger, Jag’s V-6 posts a 20-hp advantage over the Porsche’s, peaking at 380 in the S trim tested here. ZF’s ubiquitous eight-speed automatic sends torque to all four wheels, as it does in every F-Pace that Jaguar plans to bring to the U.S. Our example is one of 275 First Edition F-Paces, loaded up with 22-inch Pirelli P Zeros, an 825-watt Meridian stereo pounding through 17 speakers, Jaguar’s new In­Control Touch Pro 10.2-inch infotainment interface, and more. Total retail price: $71,095.

Aired up and topped off, we charted a course for Caldwell, Ohio, tucked into the state’s southeast corner near the Ohio River and the West Virginia state line. Here, where the roads swell and pitch across the Allegheny Plateau, we began to see the F-Pace and Macan as more than just a pair of new vehicles. Maybe crossovers like these, squatting lower, with roof- and beltlines creeping back toward the ground, portend a gradual shift away from wannabe off-roaders and back toward the lower-center-of-gravity car architectures on which the crossover boom was born. Or maybe they’re just flukes. Even if that is the case, they’re delightful flukes.

2017 Jaguar F-Pace S First Edition

Second place: Lights in the Darkness.

A little larger than the Macan and a lot ­sexi­er, the F-Pace blends the requisite crossover stance and Jaguar’s corporate face with rear haunches and taillights reminiscent of the company’s F-type ­roadster. It’s a modern and more artful interpretation of the backwoods Corvette-on-a-Blazer-frame mash-ups that you see on YouTube, and it’s a stunner, particularly in profile and from the rear.

The F-Pace also stuns from behind the wheel, a congruent follow-up to the excellent F-type and XE. Its variable-ratio steering rack is hypersensitive, snapping to attention immediately off-center and piping feedback up to the driver’s palms. And the chassis commanded by that steering boasts a neutrality rare in the crossover realm, rotating off throttle before a poke of the accelerator tucks everything back in line. The all-wheel-drive system sends torque exclusively rearward until it senses a need for it at the front end. In extreme conditions, it can divert up to half the engine’s output forward.

It might be late to the luxury-brand-SUV party, but the F-Pace is a fine presentation of Jaguar character in a sensibly sized and attractive package.

But those 22-inch wheels that look so good, and the Pirellis that grip so well, can often overpower the dampers, transmitting impacts into the cabin that the Macan is able to filter out. The tires also tram-line on uneven freeway surfaces while the Porsche tracks true. And even in dynamic mode, which firms up the adaptive dampers, the F-Pace moves around more on its springs. While both stick to the skidpad at 0.88 g, the Porsche pulls through the slalom a skosh faster on account of its ­superior body control. And while their 70-to-0-mph braking perform­ances are nearly identical—160 feet for the Jaguar and 157 for the Porsche—the F-Pace’s pedal travel starts with a moment of worrisome squish. It’s progressive once the driver pushes through, but the imprecise initial reaction saps confidence.

Jaguar did, however, nail the packaging basics on its first crossover. It seems likely that notes were passed between the Jaguar and Land Rover R&D teams. Occupants sit upright, with excellent lines of sight and plenty of room front and rear. It might look as if it belongs in a different size class, but the F-Pace isn’t actually much larger than the Macan at all, measuring just 1.6 inches longer and 1.4 taller, with 2.6 inches more wheelbase. But as soon as anyone needs to climb into the back seat, the F-Pace again seems one size up, with real space in back for adults—even three of them, in a pinch—while time in the back of the Macan rates as punishment for everybody. And no mere pretty face, the F-Pace is rated to tow 5290 pounds while the Macan is cleared to tug 4409.

It’s spacious, but the Jag’s interior lacks the fastidious detailing and cohesive sense of quality that the Porsche’s exhibits. The latter’s materials feel richer and the design better realized. Jaguar’s InControl Touch Pro touchscreen infotainment system organizes vehicle functions in a far neater manner than Porsche’s button explosion, but while it is quicker than the brand’s last-generation system, there’s still a fair bit of lag between screen poke and response. And a back button that sometimes takes you back one menu and sometimes pitches you all the way to the home screen is one sure way to raise the driver’s pulse.

Those drivers who do probe its limits will find the F-Pace an appealing blend of engagement and practicality. And those who need to regularly transport more than two adults will appreciate its more spacious second row. But for drivers seeking enlightenment in a crossover, Porsche’s light burns just a little bit brighter.

2017 Porsche Macan GTS

First place: Lights in the Darkness.

Initially, this felt a little bit like throwing the Jaguar to the wolves—or, given the English translation of the Indonesian word macan, to the tigers. Catfight, indeed. Is the regular F-Pace, even a fully trimmed one, a fair match for the tightly focused Macan GTS? Well, they line up on price, and most of the stuff that makes a Macan a GTS is available on other Macans as well. A lightly spec’d Turbo or a loaded S would keep the prices close but even ­further tilt the scales in performance and features. If you’re looking for a crossover that doesn’t act like one, Porsche can provide it in a variety of flavors.

All share an inherent greatness. The Macan was our unequivocal comfort champ, even with sport seats so extreme that one must climb up over the thigh ­bolster to get out. From outside, both the Macan and the F-Pace sound spectacular. Associate online editor Joseph Capparella noted that if you heard them coming through the woods, you’d never expect these two little school buses to pop out. But climb aboard and fire them up, and the Jaguar, from the inside, just moans into consciousness, while the Macan starts with an authori­ta­tive snarl and settles into the bassy burble that identifies serious sporting machines.

Top: The Macan’s center console is so button-intensive, it looks like two battling keyboards. Bottom left: It’s light on space, but it’s also light on its feet.

Engage the launch control that comes with the Sport Chrono package, wind up the 3.0-liter twin-turbo six before releasing the brakes, and the Macan hits 60 mph in just 4.4 seconds, almost a full second ahead of the Jag. It maintains that lead through the quarter-mile, posting 13 seconds flat to the Jag’s 13.9 and 105 mph to the leaper’s 102.

The PDK gearbox snaps off shifts so quickly that it sounds like a record skipping, but it’s remarkably civilized under lighter loads as well. Originally a performance-­enhancing development, this dual-clutch is now a model of smoothness for automatic transmissions of all types. And few vehicles on the market have better brakes than the Macan’s firm and progressive pedal.

While the steering is nice and heavy, that’s about the only thing it has going for it—except that it commands a more buttoned-down chassis. Even trying to upset the Macan by sawing at the wheel ­mid-turn doesn’t do much. It simply follows its front axle around. Both our drivers had exciting moments in the Jaguar over a lumpy chicane-like turn on our drive route, while the Porsche plowed over the crest unfazed.

Stuttgart’s stylists withheld few flourishes on the Macan, from the recessed taillights with their protruding central rib to the shifter that looks like the metal bones of the Terminator’s robotic forearm. The rest of the interior is a rich blend of soft black leather, Alcantara, brushed-aluminum trim, and contrasting stitching. It is, however, so overloaded with buttons that Porsche had to hide a few. The one to activate the heated steering wheel is tucked into the split bottom spoke. We discovered it by accident when lazily hooking a finger through the wheel on the highway. And the external release for the rear hatch is on the bottom of the rear-wiper mount. Owners, read your manuals. Button overload is a fact of life with modern Porsches.

That the brand’s DNA can be translated so purely into a crossover is heartening. And that it’s not the only brand doing such a good job is exponentially so. Maybe these two foretell a future strain of the crossover boom that morphs back into five-door cars and sports wagons. But even if that’s not where the trend is leading, we like where it’s already led.

Final Scoring, Performance Data, and Complete Specs

Jaguar and Porsche prove that an elevated center of gravity and a mainstream mission need not preclude a serious sense of fun.

2017 Jaguar F-Pace S First Edition 2017 Porsche Macan GTS
VEHICLE
PRICE AS TESTED $71,095 $77,255
BASE PRICE $70,695 $68,250
DIMENSIONS
LENGTH 186.3 inches 184.7 inches
WIDTH 76.2 inches 76.1 inches
HEIGHT 65.0 inches 63.6 inches
WHEELBASE 113.1 inches 110.5 inches
FRONT TRACK 64.6 inches 65.0 inches
REAR TRACK 65.1 inches 65.3 inches
INTERIOR VOLUME F: 51 cu ft
R: 45 cu ft
F: 52 cu ft
R: 44 cu ft
CARGO BEHIND F: 64 cu ft
R: 34 cu ft
F: 53 cu ft
R: 18 cu ft
TOWING
MAX 5290 lb 4409 lb
POWERTRAIN
ENGINE supercharged DOHC 24-valve V-6
183 cu in (2995 cc)
twin-turbocharged DOHC 24-valve V-6
183 cu in (2997 cc)
POWER HP @ RPM 380 @ 6500 360 @ 6000
TORQUE LB-FT @ RPM 332 @ 4500 369 @ 1650
REDLINE / FUEL CUTOFF 6800/6800 rpm 6800/7000 rpm
LB PER HP 11.8 12.5
DRIVELINE
TRANSMISSION 8-speed automatic 7-speed dual-clutch automatic
DRIVEN WHEELS all all
GEAR RATIO:1/
MPH PER 1000 RPM/
MAX MPH
1 4.71/5.0/34
2 3.14/7.6/51
3 2.11/11.4/77
4 1.67/14.4/98
5 1.29/18.6/126
6 1.00/24.0/155
7 0.84/28.6/145
8 0.68/35.9/135
1 3.69/5.0/35
2 2.15/8.7/61
3 1.41/13.3/93
4 1.03/18.0/126
5 0.79/24.4/159
6 0.63/31.2/150
7 0.52/37.6/140
AXLE RATIO:1 3.73 2.94
CHASSIS
SUSPENSION F: control arms, coil springs, anti-roll bar
R: multilink, coil springs, anti-roll bar
F: multilink, air springs, anti-roll bar
R: multilink, air springs, anti-roll bar
BRAKES F: 13.8-inch vented disc
R: 12.8-inch vented disc
F: 14.2-inch vented disc
R: 13.0-inch vented disc
STABILITY CONTROL partially defeatable, traction off fully defeatable, competition mode, launch control
TIRES Pirelli P Zero
265/40R-22 106Y
Michelin Latitude Sport 3
F: 265/45R-20 104Y
R: 295/40R-20 106Y
C/D TEST RESULTS
ACCELERATION
0–30 MPH 2.0 sec 1.4 sec
0–60 MPH 5.3 sec 4.4 sec
0–100 MPH 13.2 sec 11.7 sec
0–130 MPH 27.3 sec 22.7 sec
¼-MILE @ MPH 13.9 sec @ 102 13.0 sec @ 105
ROLLING START, 5–60 MPH 5.7 sec 5.4 sec
TOP GEAR, 30–50 MPH 3.3 sec 3.1 sec
TOP GEAR, 50–70 MPH 4.3 sec 3.9 sec
TOP SPEED 155 mph (mfr’s claim) 159 mph (mfr’s claim)
CHASSIS
BRAKING 70–0 MPH 160 ft 157 ft
ROADHOLDING,
300-FT-DIA SKIDPAD
0.88 g 0.88 g
610-FT SLALOM 40.6 mph* 41.1 mph
WEIGHT
CURB 4501 lb 4492 lb
%FRONT/%REAR 51.0/49.0 56.2/43.8
CG HEIGHT 26.5 in 24.0 in
FUEL
TANK 16.6 gal 19.8 gal
RATING 91 octane 93 octane
EPA COMBINED/CITY/HWY 20/18/23 mpg 19/17/23 mpg
C/D 600-MILE TRIP 16 mpg 15 mpg
PRACTICAL STOWAGE
NO. OF 9 X 14 X 22-IN BOXES, SEATS UP/FOLDED 7/20 6/16
LENGTH OF PIPE 125.5 in 124.5 in
LARGEST FLAT PANEL, LENGTH X WIDTH 70.0 x 40.3 in 6.5 x 40.5 in
SOUND LEVEL
IDLE 40 dBA 46 dBA
FULL THROTTLE 81 dBA 78 dBA
70-MPH CRUISE 69 dBA 69 dBA

*stability-control inhibited

Final Results
Max Pts. Available 2017 Porsche Macan GTS 2017 Jaguar F-Pace S First Edition
RANK 1 2
VEHICLE
DRIVER COMFORT 10 9 9
ERGONOMICS 10 9 8
REAR-SEAT COMFORT 5 3 5
REAR-SEAT SPACE* 5 5 5
TOWING CAPACITY* 5 2 5
CARGO SPACE* 5 4 5
FEATURES/AMENITIES* 10 6 10
FIT AND FINISH 10 10 8
INTERIOR STYLING 10 10 8
EXTERIOR STYLING 10 8 10
REBATES/EXTRAS* 5 0 1
AS-TESTED PRICE* 20 18 20
SUBTOTAL 105 84 94
POWERTRAIN
1/4-MILE ACCELERATION* 20 20 16
FLEXIBILITY* 5 3 4
FUEL ECONOMY* 10 9 10
ENGINE NVH 10 10 8
TRANSMISSION 10 10 8
SUBTOTAL 55 52 46
CHASSIS
PERFORMANCE* 20 20 20
STEERING FEEL 10 8 9
BRAKE FEEL 10 9 7
HANDLING 10 10 8
RIDE 10 10 8
SUBTOTAL 60 57 52
EXPERIENCE
FUN TO DRIVE 25 22 22
GRAND TOTAL 245 215 214

These objective scores are calculated from the vehicle’s dimensions, capacities, rebates and extras, and/or test results.

Galerry : https://goo.gl/ScCokC

(caranddriver.com, https://goo.gl/RFeUtg)

Comments

comments

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn