Asus Zenfone 3 vs Nubia Z11 MiniS VS Xiaomi MI Note 2 Camera Review

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

IMX318 is the latest Exmor RS Sony sesnor and it’s also the first 23MP sensor to supply for the third manufacturers. Since Asus Zenfone 3 first released it, Chinese manufacturers like Smartisan M1/M1L, Xiaomi MI Note 2 and Nubia Z11 MiniS also adopt it. So why do they all use it? What’s the real effect about their camera? Today we will compare Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe, Nubia Z11 MiniS,Xiaomi mi note 2 camera which all use IMX318.

20161103_195711_88

Camera Hardware Comparison

First, under the same camera specs, how much does the software algorithm from the manufacturer affect the real image?
Second, ignoring the cost, will the signal pixel of IMX318 bring the nice quality at night?

Standard and Size

We compare them by two big stages, first, it’s the basic function about camera experience such as focusing speed, fast shutter, film rate, HDR processing speed, the night mode automatically, richness of the camera, etc. Second, it’s the analysis, white balance, noise control, light-in, etc.

Camera Interface

20161103_192638_178_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

nubia Z11 miniS Camera Interface

20161103_192638_602_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Xiaomi MI Note 2 Camera Interface

20161103_192639_49_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe Camera Interface

All of them supports auto mode, manual mode, supporting HDR, beautification, panoramic mode, etc.

Nubia Z11 MiniS camera interface has many unique features, such as electronic aperture, macro mode, in macro mode, it can capture the object boundary actively, it has faster shutter speed and excellent image effect.

Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has its unique PixelMaster3.0 with many funny and practical picture mode such as scene depth, which can strengthen the blurring of the background to imitate the bigger aperture camera effect. It provides time to back mode, just press the shutter before 3 seconds to after 1 seconds, users can adjust the time dial to choose, it is quite playable.

Basic Experience

First, The shutter responding speed and viewing screen delay: all have fast shutter response, just press the shutter, it can finish taking photos immediately under the enough light. Nubia Z11 MiniS and Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe have fluent viewing screen without any delay. Xiaomi MI Note 2 viewing screen is a little stuck with obvious delay.

Second, Focusing speed and Image rate:  all have fast focusing speed, under the dim light, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe shows the three mixed focus, whose focus speed is faster than other two. In most scene, all can capture nice photos, Xiaomi MI Note 2 has a little slow focus speed under the macro scene, and lose focus sometimes.

Third, Automation: They all support auto HDR mode, under the strong light, they will launch HDR automatically, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has one HDR Pro mode which is helpful to improve image quality in HDR mode.

Fourth, The responding speed under HDR and Night Viewing Mode: after launching HDR mode, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has faster responding speed which almost finish at the same time. Xiaomi mi note 2 has a little delay, Nubia Z11 MiniS has about half second delay. Under the night mode, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has obvious processing time after pressing shutter which needs to wait and then see the final image.

Real Sample Analysis

All samples below listed from left to right is Nubia Z11 MiniS, Xiaomi MI Note 2, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe.

First, Analysis

As for phones’ camera analysis, it’s the performance about showing details when taking the photos, the higher the analysis is, the more the details that enlarging the photos shows, so pixel improvement will be the best way to enhance the analysis.

63a2eeb1jw1f9f56e6srij21kw0e9795_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

63a2eeb1jw1f9f56f23zzj21kw0cpwi8_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

63a2eeb1jw1f9f56g558lj21kw0cpgp2_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Central part enlarging partially

63a2eeb1jw1f9f56h5tg6j21kw0cp77t_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Edge position partial enlargement

Due to large focal length, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe wins over others in analysis.Nubia Z11 MiniS has conservative exposure control under the daylight, losing exposure is obvious, the increasing noise in the dark part leads to its analysis second to Xiaomi mi note 2. But Xiaomi mi note 2 has not high analysis itself.

63a2eeb1jw1f9f56imoblj21kw0e9tga-1_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac63a2eeb1jw1f9f56jv542j21kw0cpafq_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

In white balance, Nubia Z11 MiniS shows blue and cold color partially, Xiaomi mi note 2 has a little green partially, and Zenfone 3 Deluxe shows the best and most stable white balance and is close to the real scene.

HDR function

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5aknnsqj21kw0e9wma_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Without Launching HDR

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5am5cbsj21kw0e9gu2_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Launch HDR

After launching HDR, Nubia Z11 MINIS has the process of reducing the dark part and improving the dark part, but the overall picture contrast has reduced, losing the level to some degree.

Xiaomi MI Note 2 improved its overall brightness to several level, HDR algorithm needs to be improved. After launching HDR, the saturation of image has been improved obviously, and the white balance also has changed.

Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has slight HDR processing, only improving brightness of the dark and bright part. We even can’t see the difference between start or turn off HDR.

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5ap9d6nj21kw0pbaf6_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac63a2eeb1jw1f9f5ar29flj21kw0cp77b_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5ary8ejj21kw0pbjyk_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5b18gowj21kw0e97cd_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Glare Control

Xiaomi MI Note 2 is worst in glare control, Nubia Z11 MiniS is the best one, and Zenfone 3 ranks the second.

Noise control

Xiaomi MI Note 2 image looks clean, but the analysis is the worst in three. Nubia Z11 MiniS performs best, Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe is between them.

Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe has a low light mode, it can get very clear image by longer exposure.

20161103_192646_44_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Color Saturation

Asus Zenfone 3 Deluxe color saturation has reduced and is not better than other twos. The color looks darker. Xiaomi MI Note 2 has highest color saturation which is more attractive, Nubia Z11 MiniS ranks the second.

63a2eeb1jw1f9f5b3nvfyj21kw0e97dy_%e5%89%af%e6%9c%ac

Conclusion

According to the review, we can see Sony IMX318 has more stable performance, even under the low light. So Asus Zenfone 3, Nubia Z11 MiniS and Xiaomi MI Note 2 have their own advantages. Right now you can see which one has the best camera.

(igeekphone.com, https://goo.gl/fDCvFK)

Comments

comments

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn